Developer Notes on CQL Development

  1. If you aren't good with yacc/lex you probably should do some homework before you start. CQL development is all about building and walking a syntax tree. It's possible to make local changes without knowing the details but it can be hard to figure out where to make changes without context.

  2. CQL development is basically test driven, to create a new feature:

    1. Add the language feature to test.sql
    2. run test.sh; it will fail due to parse error
    3. Add the syntax to cql.y and create the necessary tree pieces in ast.h
    4. run test.sh; when it passes use ok.sh to install this as the new reference baseline.
    5. Add a test case to sem_test.sql that uses your new feature. sem_test.sql can contain pattern matching for the semantic output.
    6. run test.sh; it will fail because it will find an AST node it doesn't understand
    7. edit sem.c to do the analysis for your new node type
    8. adjust the verification in sem_test.sql accordingly
    9. run test.sh until it passes making fixes as needed
    10. there will be new diff output and it will be spitting out the diffs, if you are happy with the validation and the new output run ok.sh to create new reference output; note the pattern matching validations will still fail if the output goes bad even if the reference comparison is good, the reference output is a double check
    11. add code that uses your new feature to cg_test.sql, this is the code gen test, verifications using pattern matching are also allowed there
    12. run test.sh
    13. it will fail because codegen doesn't know about your new feature
    14. edit cg_c.c (or a different code gen if you're doing test helpers or some such) to support your new code
    15. cycle running test.sh until it passes
    16. run ok.sh when you're happy with the diffs again
    17. Add code that runs your new feature using run_test.sql
    18. Run test.sh, if your codegen was perfect it could pass; it probably won't at first
    19. fix your code until it's done; you shouldn't need to run ok.sh at this point
    20. run cov.sh to confirm 100% coverage
    21. sanity check the GCC build (I use a linux box for this)
  3. Get a solid code review and land as usual.

By the time you have done this you will have passed the tests dozens of times and you will know exactly what your code is doing to the entire battery of cql combinations. Missing tests can be painful and cause downstream regressions so be ruthless about adding enough combinations and validating the essential parts. The snapshot diffing is helpful but the real gating is done by the pattern matching logic.

Note: none of this works unless you are standing the main source directory

Note: the test scripts make a lot of turds, at this point almost everything should be going into the out directory but it wasn't always so. You can use make clean to get rid of the build stuff wherever it may be. Alternatively use source control to get rid of any junk.